All-Time 2nd Team All-Stars (36)

1990 - Joe Green - WVC Division II

1991 - Justin Arcadipane - WVC Division II

1991 - Craig Hoover - WVC Division II

1995 - Brian Shahum - WVC Division II

1997 - Mike Fazen - LSL AAA

1997 - Sean Timms - LSL AAA

1998 - Graig Arcurie - LSL AAA

1998 - Ed Lozada - LSL AAA

2001 - Chris Vilello - LSL Division 1

2002 - Greg Patane - LSL Division B

2002 - David Timms - LSL Division B

2004 - Jeff Bochicchio - LSL Division 1

2004 - Willie Dolph - LSL Division 1

2005 - Kyle Loftus - LSL Division 1

2005 - Jon Tyson - LSL Division 1

2006 - Josh Hicks - LSL Division 1

2007 - Brian Cebulko - LSL Division 1

2007 - Ryan Willie - LSL Division 1

2008 - Marc Eastman - LSL Division 1

2008 - Mark Gombita - LSL Division 1

2009 - Kurt Knott - LSL Division 1

2010 - Chett Havenstrite - LSL Division 1

2010 - Dan Tarr - LSL Division 1

2012 - Mike DePietro - LSL Division 2

2012 - Billy Roman - LSL Division 2

2013 - Blake Hawkins - LSL Division 2

2013 - Matt Lees - LSL Division 2

2013 - Billy Roman - LSL Division 2

2014 - Jake Montana - LSL Division 2

2014 - Billy Roman - LSL Division 2

2015 - Blake Hawkins - LSL Division 2

2015 - Ben Stivala - LSL Division 2

2015 - AJ Tonkin - LSL Division 2

2016 - Chris Wendt - LSL Division 1

2018 - Jason Parola - LSL Division 1

2019 - Taggart Loescher - LSL Division 1